STATIC LEARN / TEACHER GUIDE & KEY
Evaluate a source before using it
Grade 7 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Check authorship, evidence, relevance, and corroboration.
Prepare & include
Materials: Fictional source excerpt; Source-check organizer
Support: Provide a source-check template and one short example.
Stretch: Explain what new information would change the decision to rely on the source.
Five-day teaching sequence
- Day 1: A striking online claim names an expert but provides no method or evidence. What must we check before relying on it?
- Day 2: Why are three websites repeating the same press release not necessarily three independent confirmations?
- Day 3: Evaluate a short source using a claim-evidence trail and name one reason to use it cautiously.
- Day 4: Evaluate two public, nonprivate sources about one educational question. Record their authorship, evidence, and limitations.
- Day 5: Revisit the lesson with a fresh example. Use the exit question and ask the learner to show, point, draw, type or explain their reasoning.
Worked reasoning
Use a fictional article claiming a new study method doubles scores. Identify the author, publication context, date and actual evidence cited. Ask whether the study population and outcome match the question being researched. A relevant credential alone does not establish the specific claim. Look for the original research or independent corroboration. Trace repeated claims back to their source so copies do not masquerade as separate evidence.
Notice: The learner judges reliability only by appearance, domain ending or author fame.
Respond: Check authorship, methods, evidence, relevance and corroboration together rather than treating one cue as decisive.
Practice key
1. B — What data or records support the claim?. Evidence matters more than presentation.
2. B — No. They depend on the same underlying source.
Exit-check key
1. C — Read the cited original study’s methods and results.. The original evidence helps test whether the article accurately represents the study.
2. C — A relevant publication date. Timing matters when information can change.
Evidence to look for
Specific claim identified Evidence traced Relevance and independence considered