STATIC LEARN / STUDENT LEARNING SHEET
Evaluate a source before using it
Grade 7 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Check authorship, evidence, relevance, and corroboration.
The idea
A polished page or confident headline does not establish reliability. Ask who created it, when, for what purpose, and with what evidence. Independent support can strengthen a claim. Several pages repeating one unverified statement are not independent confirmation.
A worked example
Use a fictional article claiming a new study method doubles scores. Identify the author, publication context, date and actual evidence cited. Ask whether the study population and outcome match the question being researched. A relevant credential alone does not establish the specific claim. Look for the original research or independent corroboration. Trace repeated claims back to their source so copies do not masquerade as separate evidence.
Show the idea in your own way
Evaluate two public, nonprivate sources about one educational question. Record their authorship, evidence, and limitations.
Practice & explain
1. Which question most directly checks evidence?
- Is the headline exciting?
- What data or records support the claim?
- Does the page use my favorite color?
2. Do three pages copying the same unverified post provide three independent confirmations?
- Yes
- No
A fresh exit check
1. Which step most directly checks an article’s study claim?
- Count the decorative images.
- Assume a familiar author cannot be wrong.
- Read the cited original study’s methods and results.
2. Which source detail helps judge a changing claim?
- Only the font size
- A decorative badge with no explanation
- A relevant publication date