STATIC LEARN / TEACHER GUIDE & KEY
A claim needs evidence
Grade 6 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Distinguish a claim, supporting evidence, and reasoning.
Prepare & include
Materials: Invented observation log; Three-box organizer
Support: Use three labeled boxes and sentence starters.
Stretch: Describe an alternative explanation and evidence that could help assess it.
Five-day teaching sequence
- Day 1: A claim about a school reading corner sounds promising. What evidence and reasoning would make it more than a slogan?
- Day 2: Why is “everyone loved it” weaker than a described observation?
- Day 3: Write a narrow claim, one relevant evidence statement and a reasoning link. Add one limitation.
- Day 4: Write a recommendation using an invented observation or data set. Explain the connection and its limit.
- Day 5: Revisit the lesson with a fresh example. Use the exit question and ask the learner to show, point, draw, type or explain their reasoning.
Worked reasoning
Use an invented claim: the new reading corner increased voluntary reading during one observed lunch period. Add a bounded observation: twelve students used it during a twenty-minute count, compared with five at the old corner during a similar period. Explain why the count is relevant, then state limits such as different days or other changes. Evidence supports a claim through reasoning; it does not remove every alternative explanation.
Notice: The learner repeats a claim as its own evidence.
Respond: Ask what someone observed, measured or documented, then explain how that information bears on the claim.
Practice key
1. A — The library should offer a quiet study hour. The proposal recommends a scheduled quiet hour.
2. C — 18 of 24 respondents requested quiet space. The survey count is relevant to the recommendation.
Exit-check key
1. A — An observation log records twelve readers during the stated period.. The observation log is a specific, examinable source with a defined scope.
2. A — The respondents may not represent everyone. Who answered affects what the survey can support.
Evidence to look for
A distinct claim Checkable evidence A logical link and stated limit