STATIC LEARN / STUDENT LEARNING SHEET
A claim needs evidence
Grade 6 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Distinguish a claim, supporting evidence, and reasoning.
The idea
Original proposal: “The library should offer a quiet study hour. In our invented survey, 18 of 24 respondents requested a quieter place. A scheduled hour would create a predictable option without requiring every hour to be silent.” Evidence should be relevant. A small survey can inform a decision without proving what every community member wants.
A worked example
Use an invented claim: the new reading corner increased voluntary reading during one observed lunch period. Add a bounded observation: twelve students used it during a twenty-minute count, compared with five at the old corner during a similar period. Explain why the count is relevant, then state limits such as different days or other changes. Evidence supports a claim through reasoning; it does not remove every alternative explanation.
Show the idea in your own way
Write a recommendation using an invented observation or data set. Explain the connection and its limit.
Practice & explain
1. What is the main claim?
- The library should offer a quiet study hour
- Exactly 24 people exist in the community
- All library hours must be silent
2. Which is a supporting piece of evidence?
- A speaker repeats the claim loudly
- The word library has seven letters
- 18 of 24 respondents requested quiet space
A fresh exit check
1. Which sentence provides evidence rather than only repeating a claim?
- An observation log records twelve readers during the stated period.
- The corner is successful because it is successful.
- It is obviously the best place for everyone.
2. Which limitation should a reader consider?
- The respondents may not represent everyone
- No one may ask questions
- A survey automatically proves all preferences