STATIC LEARN / TEACHER GUIDE & KEY
Compare arguments and their assumptions
Grade 10 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Explain agreement, disagreement, and underlying priorities.
Prepare & include
Materials: Two invented arguments; Comparison chart
Support: Use a parallel argument chart.
Stretch: Propose evidence that could change one factual assumption while leaving a value disagreement open.
Five-day teaching sequence
- Day 1: Two arguments support a school garden but disagree about allocating space. What assumptions might drive the disagreement?
- Day 2: Why might agreement on the garden’s value still leave disagreement about the design?
- Day 3: Compare two arguments using claims, reasons, assumptions, agreement and a remaining decision criterion.
- Day 4: Compare two original arguments on a low-stakes shared-space choice. Identify assumptions and needed evidence.
- Day 5: Revisit the lesson with a fresh example. Use the exit question and ask the learner to show, point, draw, type or explain their reasoning.
Worked reasoning
Use two invented arguments: one prioritizes maximum vegetable yield, while another prioritizes accessible paths and a shared seating area. Identify their shared support for a garden and their different criteria for success. Separate factual disputes from value priorities. Ask what each assumes about users, space and outcomes. Evidence can test yield or access claims without automatically resolving every priority choice.
Notice: The learner reduces disagreement to one writer being uninformed.
Respond: Represent each argument’s strongest reasons, then distinguish evidence questions from priority conflicts.
Practice key
1. B — Useful library access. Both argue about how the library should serve people.
2. B — Staff support quality. B emphasizes staffing and visitors’ need for help.
Exit-check key
1. C — Which users and outcomes does each writer treat as most important?. Priorities and assumptions shape what each writer counts as a successful design.
2. B — Costs, hourly use, and unmet help needs. Those data address the actual decisions.
Evidence to look for
Fair summaries An identified underlying assumption A meaningful relationship beyond “same/different”