STATIC LEARN / STUDENT LEARNING SHEET
Compare arguments and their assumptions
Grade 10 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Explain agreement, disagreement, and underlying priorities.
The idea
Two original arguments concern a longer library opening. A: “Extend hours because evening access serves workers and students.” B: “Improve daytime staffing first because visitors need help, not only an open door.” A comparison should not assume the positions are mutually exclusive. Identify what facts would clarify the tradeoff.
A worked example
Use two invented arguments: one prioritizes maximum vegetable yield, while another prioritizes accessible paths and a shared seating area. Identify their shared support for a garden and their different criteria for success. Separate factual disputes from value priorities. Ask what each assumes about users, space and outcomes. Evidence can test yield or access claims without automatically resolving every priority choice.
Show the idea in your own way
Compare two original arguments on a low-stakes shared-space choice. Identify assumptions and needed evidence.
Practice & explain
1. What do both arguments broadly value?
- Closing all services
- Useful library access
- Eliminating help
2. What does argument B prioritize?
- Only later hours
- Staff support quality
- The building’s name
A fresh exit check
1. Which question best exposes an underlying design assumption?
- Which font appears in the argument?
- Can disagreement be ignored because both like gardens?
- Which users and outcomes does each writer treat as most important?
2. Which evidence would help compare the proposals?
- An unrelated poll
- Costs, hourly use, and unmet help needs
- Only the speakers’ favorite books