A source-based museum exhibit
A source-based exhibit should identify original evidence, replicas, reconstruction and interpretation clearly. An attractive complete object can hide which parts survive and which were imagined. Compare a find record with a reconstruction report before writing a label. A bounded claim should cite observations and name an unresolved question. The fragments and replica below are original classroom models, not museum objects being newly authenticated; no real artifact handling or collecting is required.
A worked example
Original exhibit dossier. Record A — modeled fragment register: three pottery pieces join to form part of a vessel’s lower body; the clay thickness matches across the joins; the exterior base is blackened; one repair hole survives. No rim, handle, painted surface or residue analysis is recorded. Record B — original reconstruction report: a classroom replica copies the joined lower-body curve; its tall neck and handle are proposed from comparisons with other vessel shapes; its red paint is a designer’s choice, not an observed pigment. Worked reasoning: the joins support part of the body shape, and blackening raises a use question. A label must distinguish those observations from the hypothetical upper form and invented color; blackening alone does not identify a cooked food.
- Inventory the surviving joins, blackening and repair hole from Record A, separating observations from possible uses.
- Compare each replica feature in Record B with the fragment register and code it observed, comparison-based or designer-added.
- Draft a replica label that identifies the copied lower body and hypothetical neck, handle and paint; complete practice before revising.
- Write a bounded use interpretation with two observed details and a question about residue or form that the dossier cannot answer.
- Assemble the fragment description, reconstruction key and revised labels using both records, then take the independent check.
Open the printable learning material