The Indus region and city evidence
Indus-region urban remains support careful questions about planning, craft work and exchange. Repeated measures and drainage features are observations; an exact political constitution requires other evidence. Indus signs do not have an agreed decipherment, so a seal cannot simply be read as a ruler’s command. Compare observable similarities while marking missing information. The dossier is an original model, with invented building locations and weights rather than a report from one real Indus excavation.
A worked example
Original Indus city-evidence dossier. Record A — schematic block plan: three houses face a straight lane; each has a covered drain leading into a larger street drain; a well stands at the lane’s end. No builder names, dates of individual repairs or rules for maintenance are supplied. Record B — modeled craft inventory from two workshops: both contain stone weights of 1, 2 and 4 model mass units; one has bead fragments and the other shell offcuts. Each has a small seal with several untranscribed signs. The model supplies no reading of those signs. Worked reasoning: repeated drainage arrangements and weight relationships support questions about shared practices. They do not identify a king, prove equal wealth or decipher a law.
- Draw the lane, houses, well and linked drains in Record A; separate visible arrangements from guesses about who planned them.
- Make a workshop comparison using Record B’s weights, bead fragments, shell offcuts and seals without assigning invented readings to the signs.
- Compare two observations supporting organized practices, one from each record; complete practice and mark an unsupported political inference.
- Write a city-evidence label distinguishing common measurements from identical workshop products, and identify a maintenance question left by Record A.
- Present the block plan and workshop chart, cite both records and state what undeciphered signs cannot currently establish before the check.
Open the printable learning material