Historical questions and evidence
Historical inquiry begins with a question, not a preferred story. An artifact inventory states observable features before proposing a use. A second record can strengthen, narrow or challenge an interpretation. Compare where objects occurred, what survives and what was not recorded. A cooking pot does not identify its owner or reveal every meal. The original models below let you practice reasoning; they are not finds from a real excavation.
A worked example
Original teaching dossier, invented for analysis. Record A — store-area inventory: four repaired pottery jars, charred grain in two jars, a grinding stone, and no recorded human names; all were found on the same floor. Record B — adjacent cooking-area inventory: two soot-darkened pots, a hearth and mixed plant seeds; no jar contents survived there. The areas are connected by a doorway, but neither record dates the doorway. Worked reasoning: grain and repaired jars support a question about storage and reuse, while soot and a hearth support a question about cooking. The doorway suggests a possible connection; its unknown date prevents certainty that both areas operated together.
- List every observed object in Records A and B; put proposed uses in a separate column so evidence and inference remain distinguishable.
- Draw the two areas and their doorway from the dossier; mark the doorway date as unknown instead of inventing a chronology.
- Compare grain, seeds and soot as evidence of different activities; complete the practice questions and revise an overconfident food claim.
- Design two research questions, one about jar repair and one about cooking; identify which supplied observation makes each question investigable.
- Present a two-area evidence display using both records; state one supported interpretation and one unanswered question before taking the independent check.
Open the printable learning material