Western development and unequal power
Western development involved resource extraction, farming, cities, migration, and continuing Indigenous dispossession and resistance. Map who gains, who bears costs, and whose claims appear in the sources. A development account should identify who gained resources and who lost control of land, water, or access. Compare a treaty's promise with later policy and movement. The word development describes change; it does not establish equal benefit or erase Indigenous sovereignty. A local gold discovery can be connected to national military and political choices.
A worked example
Worked dossier: How did the Black Hills gold rush conflict with treaty commitments? Source A, Treaty of Fort Laramie of 1868, original paraphrase of the National Archives account and treaty: the United States recognized a reservation including the Black Hills for the Sioux nations' exclusive use; the Black Hills are sacred to Lakota people. Source B, NPS account of Fort Laramie in 1876, original paraphrase: Custer's 1874 expedition confirmed gold, and miners entered despite treaty restrictions; in late 1875, President Grant directed the military to leave miners alone. These are later institutional summaries of documented events, not invented eyewitness quotations. Source C, geographic relationship supplied from the treaty history: the Black Hills lie within the western part of present-day South Dakota; incoming miners sought access to land already covered by the 1868 agreement. Worked reasoning: access to valuable minerals for newcomers conflicted with promised exclusion of settlers and Lakota land rights. Neither a gold total nor a growing settlement alone measures those unequal effects.
- Identify the land promise in the 1868 treaty card and locate the Black Hills using the supplied geographic relationship; do not label the area unoccupied land.
- Sequence the treaty, the 1874 expedition, and the 1875 policy shift; explain how the later actions challenged the earlier commitment rather than assuming dates alone show cause.
- Create a gains-and-costs chart for miners, U.S. officials, and Lakota communities, then complete both practice questions using the specific treaty and policy details.
- Revise a mining-growth exhibit that lists only new wealth; add the treaty conflict, Indigenous land rights, and a source needed about water or local livelihoods.
- Present a western-development argument naming unequal power and a limit of the supplied institutional accounts; then attempt the reserved independent check without feedback.
Open the printable learning material