Questions, chronology, and evidence
A historical inquiry begins with a question and uses sources placed in time and context. Record creator, date, purpose, and the question each source can help answer. A date tells when a record was created; it may describe an earlier event. Separate a direct observation from a proposal and from a later memory. Use the fictional records below to answer how a decision developed, not to prove that every resident agreed.
A worked example
Worked dossier: How did a town decide where to build its market? All records and dates in this packet are ORIGINAL FICTIONAL CLASSROOM RECONSTRUCTIONS, not real historical letters. Source A, town clerk's notice dated March 3, 1824: the council will hear two market proposals on March 17; no site has been chosen. Source B, letter by a cart driver dated March 10, 1824: the driver favors the wharf site because unloading there avoids an uphill trip; the letter does not report a vote. Source C, clerk's minutes dated March 17, 1824: five council members chose the square and two chose the wharf; the council approved the square. Timeline data: March 3 notice; March 10 letter; March 17 hearing and vote. Worked reasoning: the letter shows one person's preference before the decision, while the minutes record a later council action. The seven council votes do not tell us the opinions of all town residents.
- Read Sources A–C and enter creator, date, purpose, and useful detail in a notebook; label every entry as fictional classroom evidence.
- Arrange the three dated records on a timeline, then distinguish the driver's proposed location from the council's recorded decision.
- Compare the notice and minutes: explain what changed between March 3 and March 17, then answer both practice questions using source letters.
- Draft two possible explanations for the driver's preference; keep the uphill route explanation and cross out a claim without supplied support.
- Present a short market-decision exhibit with a timeline, two cited details, and one missing resident perspective; then attempt the reserved independent check without feedback.
Open the printable learning material