History and geography portfolio
Begin with the supplied source or geographic model, and identify whose experience it describes and what it omits. A portfolio should show how sources, maps, and questions support an explanation and how it changed during study. Select a revised claim and explain which new source or geographic detail changed it. Record the evidence beside your claim so another learner can trace the connection. Compare a second possibility before deciding. State a limit: a small record, one perspective, or a simplified model rarely establishes every possible case.
A worked example
Worked investigation: A learner compares an early map claim with later source evidence. A supported response is: The revision can show stronger reasoning and attention to context. Reasoning: A portfolio should show how sources, maps, and questions support an explanation and how it changed during study. This conclusion applies to the supplied situation; it does not establish every possible case. Topic dossier — a self-contained fictional portfolio sample, so no previous saved work is required. Record A, early draft based on a 1900 map: market is (2,2), orchard is (4,2), school is (1,2); the learner writes that the town’s mapped land use will stay the same. Record B, newly supplied 1930 map on the same grid: market and school keep their positions; workshops replace the orchard at (4,2); station is (2,1); a railway follows y=1. Record C, revision entry: the learner changes the claim to say that the market and school continued while one recorded land use changed and a railway connection appeared. The sample is original classroom work, not an archival student record. Maps do not reveal every resident’s opinion or prove that the railway caused every change. Worked dossier reasoning: The 1930 record contradicts a claim of unchanged mapped land use at the orchard, yet supports continuity of market and school locations. A stronger revision combines both findings and leaves unrecorded causes and experiences open.
- Create source cards for both dated map records and copy the early claim into a draft/revision chart. Mark the prediction that the early map alone could not establish.
- Reconstruct matched map panels or coordinate tables and identify one continuity, one changed land use and one added transport feature using exact locations.
- Complete the practice questions, then compare the revised claim with the early draft and explain which later details justify each correction.
- Assemble a portfolio page using this complete sample or an available earlier classroom artifact. Include creator/source status, dates, a checked representation and an evidence-linked revision.
- Present the portfolio with two supporting details, a reason for the revision and one remaining uncertainty. Keep the independent assessment separate and attempt it only after the portfolio review.
Open the printable learning material