Distinguishing reasons from evidence
Read the original passage below twice, first for the situation and then for the words that support an interpretation. A reason explains why a claim might be sensible; evidence supplies information that can be checked. Label the claim, reason, and checkable record separately; explain the record’s strength and limitation. Record the evidence beside your claim so another learner can trace the connection. Compare a second possibility before deciding. State a limit: a small record, one perspective, or a simplified model rarely establishes every possible case.
A worked example
Worked investigation: Original passage: Our reading group should use a shared bookmark chart. A chart would help us return to the right sections. During a three-day trial, the group found its place without repeated searches on two days and needed one reminder on the third. The writer includes the imperfect result instead of hiding it. A supported response is: The trial record supplies evidence for the reason while showing the routine still needed a reminder.. Reasoning: A reason explains why a claim might be sensible; evidence supplies information that can be checked. This conclusion applies to the supplied situation; it does not establish every possible case.
- Read or listen to the original passage twice. Label the claim, reason, and checkable record separately; explain the record’s strength and limitation. Mark three relevant details and draft a supported response. Then spend 20–30 minutes with a chosen complete STATIC Books edition, classroom book, local-library book, or accessible text; record pages or sections and one question.
- Continue the chosen text for 20–30 minutes, using audio, shared reading, or independent reading as appropriate. Make a comparison table using at least four matched categories. Apply this week’s focus, distinguishing reasons from evidence, to a specific section; include page, chapter, or section references so the notes can be checked.
- Complete the two practice items and explain why each rejected choice conflicts with the passage. Read the chosen text for another 20–30 minutes. Write a comparison that explains one meaningful similarity, two differences, and supporting evidence. Plan a 180–250-word piece or an equivalent illustrated, recorded, typed, signed, or AAC-supported response.
- Read or listen for 20–30 minutes, revisiting an earlier section if useful. Draft the planned piece with a clear beginning or claim, linked details, and an ending. Label the claim, reason, and checkable record separately; explain the record’s strength and limitation. Use the chosen text or your own invented scene rather than copying the worked passage.
- Read or listen for 20–30 minutes and finish a response journal entry. Revise the draft after checking three references or details and one reader-access need. Share a 180–250-word finished piece or an equivalent accessible presentation, then attempt the reserved independent check without feedback.
Open the printable learning material