Primary and secondary sources
Begin with the supplied source or geographic model, and identify whose experience it describes and what it omits. A source’s relationship to the event and the question helps determine how it can be used as evidence. Record creator, time, purpose, and what each source can and cannot show. Record the evidence beside your claim so another learner can trace the connection. Compare a second possibility before deciding. State a limit: a small record, one perspective, or a simplified model rarely establishes every possible case.
A worked example
Worked investigation: A letter written during an event is compared with a later historian’s account. A supported response is: The letter is primary for some questions and the later analysis can provide context. Reasoning: A source’s relationship to the event and the question helps determine how it can be used as evidence. This conclusion applies to the supplied situation; it does not establish every possible case. Topic dossier — the historical items below are authentic records described in original words, not reproduced quotations. Record A, photograph description from the Library of Congress Wright Papers: John T. Daniels photographed the Wright aircraft lifting from its launch rail on December 17, 1903, with Orville aboard and Wilbur nearby. This describes visible content and catalog context; the image alone does not show every flight that day. Record B, diary description from the same collection: Orville’s dated December 17, 1903 diary records details of four flights, including measurements and difficulties. The description is a paraphrase, not diary wording. Record C, later National Park Service interpretation: the memorial’s educational account connects the 1903 tests with years of design and earlier experiments. This later account analyzes the event using historical records. The original letter-versus-historian worked scenario above is a classroom analogy, not an additional authentic document. Worked dossier reasoning: The 1903 photograph and diary are records from the time under study, useful for different questions. The later park interpretation is analysis and context. A description or paraphrase must not be passed off as the original item’s exact words.
- Create a source card for each supplied record, naming creator or institution, time relationship to 1903, format and what information the description actually supplies.
- Compare the photograph and diary for the question of what happened during the first flight day. Separate visible image evidence from information supplied by catalog context or diary description.
- Complete the practice questions, then explain why the later park account can provide context even though it was not created during the 1903 tests.
- Write two claims: one answerable from the supplied photograph description, and one requiring the diary or later account. Cite the record used and name a limit.
- Present a source-use guide that distinguishes authentic records, original paraphrases and the classroom analogy. Explain why primary does not mean complete or automatically correct, then attempt the reserved check.
Open the printable learning material