English III: Two accounts of the same night — reasons, evidence and warrants
An argument connects a claim to reasons and evidence through an underlying assumption called a warrant. State the connection explicitly rather than letting a number or anecdote speak for itself. Consider whether the evidence represents the population or situation being discussed. A fair response addresses the strongest relevant objection and narrows the claim when the available evidence cannot support its original scope.
A worked example
Complete original classroom text (all characters, publications and numbers here are invented for analysis):
Account A, an invented newspaper editorial: Last night’s late bus trial was a success. Thirty riders used the new service, and the route finished on schedule. The city should make the change permanent. Account B, an invented personal essay: I boarded the late bus with my work shoes in a bag. For once, I did not ask my sister to leave dinner cooling on the table. Three streets from home, the driver helped a passenger read the unfamiliar stop sign. We arrived on time. At the terminal I saw two people running toward a bus that had already left. In a classroom comparison, Devi notes that both accounts describe a useful service. The editorial turns an initial result into a policy recommendation. The essay gives one rider’s experience and leaves a question about those who missed the connection.
Worked analysis: Begin with “make the change permanent”. Its literal meaning is established by the surrounding sentences. The focused interpretation is: The editorial moves from one trial night to a recommendation requiring broader evidence. Connect this wording to one earlier or later detail before concluding. A careful paragraph identifies the language, explains the connection, and retains room for a competing reading; it does not infer the real author’s biography from the fictional scene.
- Day 1: Spend 25 minutes reading the supplied two accounts of the same night text and rereading its most complex sentences; annotate five details and write a 150-word initial interpretation of “make the change permanent”.
- Day 2: Analyze reasons, evidence and warrants by mapping three textual choices to effects; continue 25 minutes of a teacher-chosen book or reread and extend the original passage with a contrasting scene.
- Day 3: Complete both practice questions, then write a 250-word paragraph explaining “The editorial moves from one trial night to a recommendation requiring broader evidence.”; compare an alternative interpretation and record which exact words support each.
- Day 4: Write a 620–820-word analysis of two accounts of the same night focused on reasons, evidence and warrants. Develop the interpretation “The editorial moves from one trial night to a recommendation requiring broader evidence.”, use three passage details, address a plausible alternative, and submit an annotated draft with a revised final version. Continue sustained reading for 25 minutes and add a short response connecting a specific new detail to the week’s focus.
- Day 5: Complete both check questions independently, revise the draft with sentence-level changes, and submit a reading log plus a 200-word reflection on one improved analytical connection.
Open the printable learning material