STATIC LEARN / STUDENT LEARNING SHEET
Answer a counterargument with evidence
Grade 8 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Strengthen an argument by responding to a relevant objection.
The idea
Original claim: “The school should lend reusable event cups.” Counterargument: “Washing uses water.” Response: “That cost matters. The proposal should compare water, manufacturing, reuse rates, and waste before choosing a system.” A response can refine a claim rather than pretend every objection has disappeared.
A worked example
State a bounded proposal for a courtyard shade structure and the counterargument that upkeep may exceed the available budget. Distinguish relevant cost evidence from unrelated evidence that people like shade. Gather estimated installation, maintenance and replacement costs under stated assumptions. Revise the proposal if the evidence reveals a real constraint. A response can acknowledge a valid objection rather than pretending to defeat every concern.
Show the idea in your own way
Write an argument, one fair objection, and a response that identifies needed evidence.
Practice & explain
1. What concern does the counterargument raise?
- Cups have no materials
- Water used in washing
- No one attends events
2. Why is the response reasonable?
- It insults the objector
- It claims water never matters
- It acknowledges the concern and asks for relevant comparisons
A fresh exit check
1. Which evidence most directly addresses the courtyard maintenance concern?
- Documented upkeep estimates under comparable conditions.
- A list of favorite colors.
- A survey only asking whether shade looks pleasant.
2. Which evidence would help evaluate the proposal?
- Unrelated attendance guesses
- Only the cup’s nickname
- Measured washing water and actual reuse rates