STATIC LEARN / TEACHER GUIDE & KEY
Revise the reasoning, not just the wording
Grade 12 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Improve a claim by checking structure, evidence, and warranted confidence.
Prepare & include
Materials: Original flawed paragraph; Reasoning checklist
Support: Use claim/evidence/warrant annotations.
Stretch: Describe a study or source that could test the stronger version of the claim.
Five-day teaching sequence
- Day 1: A paragraph has polished sentences but a conclusion broader than its evidence. What revision improves the reasoning itself?
- Day 2: Why is replacing “every” with “many” insufficient by itself?
- Day 3: Revise a short argument by narrowing a claim, improving a warrant or naming a missing evidence requirement.
- Day 4: Revise a short original argument after a fair critique. Add a note explaining the reasoning changes.
- Day 5: Revisit the lesson with a fresh example. Use the exit question and ask the learner to show, point, draw, type or explain their reasoning.
Worked reasoning
Use an invented draft: ten volunteers liked a study app, therefore the app improves every student’s exam performance. Identify the mismatch between preference and performance, the small volunteer sample and the universal conclusion. Revise to a bounded claim about those volunteers’ reported preferences and propose performance evidence needed for the larger question. Better wording cannot replace missing support.
Notice: The learner treats revision as synonym replacement or adds confidence without additional evidence.
Respond: Trace each major claim to relevant evidence and articulate the reasoning linking them.
Practice key
1. A — Everyone loved it and it is proved best. The sample does not establish universal approval or optimality.
2. B — Most of these respondents found it useful, with broader evaluation still needed. The revision preserves the finding while qualifying its scope.
Exit-check key
1. A — These ten volunteers reported liking the app; exam effects remain untested here.. The first statement stays with the measured preference and explicitly limits the performance inference.
2. C — Replace a universal claim with a supported, limited conclusion. Claim strength must match the evidence.
Evidence to look for
A substantive reasoning change Relevant support Confidence proportional to evidence