STATIC LEARN / TEACHER GUIDE & KEY
Evaluate a policy with a clear outcome
Grade 11 · Social studies · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Define a goal, compare alternatives, and choose evidence.
Prepare & include
Materials: Fictional staffing constraint; Policy comparison grid
Support: Use a goal/options/evidence grid.
Stretch: Propose a second outcome that could reveal a tradeoff hidden by the first metric.
Five-day teaching sequence
- Day 1: Two proposed library-hour plans both promise improvement. What would count as success, and how would the plans be compared?
- Day 2: Why define the access outcome before collecting data?
- Day 3: Write a policy comparison with a goal, two options, a relevant measure, a cost and an evaluation limit.
- Day 4: Design an evaluation plan for an invented policy with a measurable goal and a comparison.
- Day 5: Revisit the lesson with a fresh example. Use the exit question and ask the learner to show, point, draw, type or explain their reasoning.
Worked reasoning
Set an invented goal: increase useful after-school access within a fixed staffing budget. Distinguish this from maximizing total opening hours at any time. Compare one later weekday closing with an added weekend session. Identify affected users, costs and a measurable outcome such as visits during needed periods. Plan a before-and-after or comparable-period evaluation while noting seasonal and other confounding changes. One metric cannot capture every value or effect.
Notice: The learner chooses an easy metric that does not match the policy goal.
Respond: Trace the metric to the stated users and need, and consider benefits, costs and unintended effects.
Practice key
1. C — Minutes users wait. Waiting time directly measures the stated goal.
2. C — To judge what changed relative to another condition. Evaluation needs a meaningful reference point.
Exit-check key
1. C — Use during the after-school periods relevant to intended users.. A measure should reflect the defined access need rather than an unrelated easy count.
2. B — Demand changed at the same time. Changing demand may affect waiting time independently of the policy.
Evidence to look for
A clear outcome Comparable alternatives Evidence linked to the goal and affected groups