STATIC LEARN / TEACHER GUIDE & KEY
Synthesize without flattening disagreement
Grade 11 · Reading & writing · Quick adventure
Learning goal: Combine source relationships into a qualified conclusion.
Prepare & include
Materials: Three fictional study summaries; Synthesis matrix
Support: Use an evidence-by-condition matrix.
Stretch: Identify a research comparison that would help distinguish context effects from method differences.
Five-day teaching sequence
- Day 1: Two studies support an intervention under different conditions, while a third reports no benefit. How can synthesis retain those differences?
- Day 2: Why is “all studies prove it works” an inaccurate synthesis?
- Day 3: Write a synthesis paragraph connecting two agreements and one difference, with an appropriately qualified conclusion.
- Day 4: Write a synthesis paragraph from three original mini-sources on an invented issue.
- Day 5: Revisit the lesson with a fresh example. Use the exit question and ask the learner to show, point, draw, type or explain their reasoning.
Worked reasoning
Use fictional summaries: study A reports a benefit in small groups, B in a short supervised setting, and C no clear benefit in an unsupervised setting. Organize agreement, condition differences and conflict rather than listing three summaries separately. Draft a qualified conclusion that benefits may depend on context, while noting that differences in methods could also explain outcomes. Do not imply the invented sources settle a real intervention.
Notice: The learner treats synthesis as source-by-source summary or a vote count.
Respond: Compare methods, populations, outcomes and limitations before forming a cross-source claim.
Practice key
1. C — The trial suggests access benefits while raising cost and sampling questions. It connects the sources while preserving different findings.
2. B — The usage log. The log records visits.
Exit-check key
1. B — Describe the differing conditions and qualify the conclusion.. Context and method differences are part of the evidence relationship and should remain visible.
2. C — The experiences may not represent all users. Selected interviews provide insight without representing everyone automatically.
Evidence to look for
Sources placed in relationship Conditions and disagreement retained A conclusion no broader than the evidence